Monday, July 14th, 2008

TerminatorToo

The Terminator is great. Terminator 2 is arguable greater. This Terminator is also great, as is this Terminator, probably, although I have never tried it.

2 projects, 1 name, an annoying issue which I would not wish on anyone. Unfortunately though, for Chris Jones of this Terminator project, it is an issue; an annoying issue which is probably compounded due to the fact that the other Terminator project is also a terminal emulator.

I feel for Chris as he is faced with 2 options, leave the name as is [and forever field questions from muppets like myself], or, change the project name. To be honest, I would not imagine either option is overly appealing; still, if I were to put myself in Chris' shoes, I think I would be inclined to change the name sooner, rather than later. I would do it for the following reasons:

Having now committed to letting Chris know what to do, it would be remiss of me to spout all this nonsense without coming up a serious contender for a suitably catchy alternative name. So, I was thinking, what about TerminatorToo? Disregarding the silly pun, it would have the advantage of users not having to mentally relearn keystrokes when typing into any tab-completion enabled environments. Just a thought.

Finally, all testiculating aside, I am interested to know what you would do if you found yourself in this situation? Of course, I am speculating, but I think Chris would be interested too.


9 Responses to “TerminatorToo”

  1. qhartman wrote,

    Definitely a tough one. Personally, I'd try to get the other project to change their name to "Termulator". It says right at the top of the page, "Terminator is a cross-platform GPL terminal emulator with advanced features not yet found elsewhere.". It seems that integrating the word "emulator" into the name would not be objectionable, and I think it's rather witty, actually.

    Alternatively, TerminatorToo is ok, but I'd be inclined to go towards something that is a little less likely to have collisions in the future. Termarranger, Termtiler, Termtabber, something along those lines. Using non-generic words as project names is a good way to avoid this problem in the first place, though sticking to that "rule" dogmatically clearly severely limits ones options

  2. Philip wrote,

    @qhartman: Your first suggestion would be ideal :) Also, Termarranger, nice name and very apt.

  3. foo wrote,

    Respect for what came before is definitely NOT the Ubuntu way.

  4. Philip wrote,

    @foo: Meow.

  5. Bjorn Ingmar Berg wrote,

    I would work towards merging with that other project. A nice way of getting rid of the duplicity, adding human resources at the same time.

    PS: I was forced to misspell my own name. The server seems to have a lobotomized / americanized view of what makes il/legal characters. Please remove this bug.

  6. Chris Jones wrote,

    Whichever option we choose, we lose. I certainly don't want to stomp all over another project, but I also don't want to lose the mindshare we have built up so far.

    Basically, fail.

  7. volksman wrote,

    I feel for the author(s) too. Not the first or last time this will happen (see libtorrent).

    I was thinking about other possible names the other day but the only one that stuck with me for some reason (cause it isn't good) was just calling it "Arnold"… :)

  8. Philip wrote,

    @Chris Jones: Like I said in the post, I feel for you and I certainly do not envy your position. Having said that, is it really all that bad? It's just a name, surely it's the idea and software that counts. If you did decide to change the name, I am sure the community would get behind you and help minimise any loss of mindshare.

    @volksman: Arnold = pure genius, I love it :)

  9. andylockran wrote,

    Hmm.. I have tried the second, but not the first. The second is on the launchpad page right?

    I'm confused now.

Add Your Comment

Use the form below to add your comment. Markdown syntax is available. Note, comments are moderated by me for spam filtering. Alternatively, feel free to contact me privately.